Search Key West arrest records without guessing which office has the file
A search for Key West arrest records can mean several different things: a booking from today, an older arrest, current jail custody, an active warrant, the police report, the criminal court case, or a statewide Florida criminal history. Those records are not kept in one database. The fastest route is to start with the Monroe County Sheriff for arrest and custody information, then use the Monroe County Clerk to verify what happened in court.
Official-source check: October 28, 2026. Government portals, fees, phone numbers, and access rules can change, so use the linked agency page for the final live status.
First decide what you actually need
| Your question | Best official source | What it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Was someone arrested recently? | MCSO Current Arrests | Recent Monroe County arrest activity by date. Confirm the location is actually Key West. |
| Was there an older arrest? | MCSO Arrest Search | Historical arrest lookup through the Sheriff’s separate search page. |
| Is the person in jail now? | MCSO Current Inmates | Current Monroe County custody status. |
| What happened after the arrest? | Monroe County Clerk Court Records | Filed criminal case, docket activity, accessible documents, and disposition. |
| Do I need the actual police/arrest report? | Key West Police or MCSO records | The narrative or report created by the arresting or investigating agency. |
| Is there an active warrant? | MCSO Active Warrants | Current warrant information published by the Sheriff. |
| Do I need a Florida-wide history? | FDLE Criminal History Record Check | Statewide Florida criminal-history search rather than a Monroe County-only lookup. |
How to search Key West arrest records in 5 steps
Open the Sheriff’s Current Arrests page
Go to the official Monroe County Sheriff Current Arrests page. It loads arrests by date. Find the correct person and check the arrest date, location, and arresting agency before treating the entry as a Key West arrest.
Check whether the person is still in custody
Open Current Inmates. A booking may remain relevant after a person has been released, so the recent-arrest page and current-inmate page answer different questions.
Use Arrest Search for an older event
If the arrest is not recent, use the separate MCSO Arrest Search. The form is loaded dynamically on the Sheriff’s site. Use the search fields shown on the live page and match more than the name whenever possible.
Verify the criminal court case
Open the Monroe County Clerk Court Records Search. Search the criminal case by first and last name, case number, or date range. Use the docket and disposition to see what the prosecution and court did after the arrest.
Request the underlying report only if you need the narrative
When Key West Police created the report, use the City’s public-records process. When the Monroe County Sheriff created it, use the Sheriff’s public-record request portal. Ask for the exact arrest or incident report rather than a vague “background check.”
How to find recent Key West arrests
The Sheriff’s Current Arrests page is the best first check for recent booking activity that reaches the Monroe County system. Because it is countywide, the location and agency fields matter. Do not assume every person appearing there was arrested inside Key West city limits.
Match full name plus another identifier when available.
Match the arrest or booking date, not just the person.
Confirm Key West location or a Key West arresting agency.
Save the booking or arrest identifier, arrest date, arresting agency, charges, and bond information if the official page displays them. These details make it much easier to find the matching court case or request a report later.
Do not use a booking charge as the final legal result. The prosecutor may file different charges, decline a charge, or the court may later dismiss or resolve the case. Our sources and verification policy explains why booking, court, and criminal-history databases must be read as separate records.
How to search older Key West arrest records
For an arrest that no longer appears on the recent list, move to the Sheriff’s Arrest Search. If you know the approximate arrest year, use that information to separate people with similar names and multiple arrest events.
If the Sheriff search does not give you enough history, search the court record next. A criminal case can remain findable even when a person is no longer in jail or the arrest is no longer on a current-booking page. For the underlying arrest narrative, submit a records request to the agency that created the report.
Best identifiers to collect before requesting an old report
- Full legal name and any known middle name or initial.
- Approximate arrest or incident date.
- Arresting agency: Key West Police, Monroe County Sheriff, or another agency.
- Booking or arrest number, incident number, or court case number if already known.
- Specific document needed, such as arrest report, incident report, or certified court disposition.
Current inmates: check custody separately from the arrest
The official MCSO Current Inmates page is the right tool for present county custody. A person can be arrested and later released, transferred, or otherwise removed from the current-inmate list, so an arrest entry alone does not answer “Are they still in jail?”
The Florida Department of State’s county-jail directory lists Monroe County’s jail at 5501 College Road, Key West, FL 33040, phone 305-293-7300, and points users to the Monroe inmate/arrest search. For general Sheriff questions, the MCSO site lists 305-289-2351 as its 24-hour non-emergency number and 305-292-7000 for headquarters.
Use Monroe County court records to verify the outcome
The Monroe County Clerk online system lets the public search criminal cases by name, case number, and date criteria. The Clerk currently states that online docket information is available for most cases filed from approximately 1990 to the present, while documents are available from 2007 to the present for most case types.
The search is limited to the first 500 results, so broad common-name searches should be narrowed. The Clerk also warns that mental-health, juvenile, and guardianship searches are restricted for the general public, and anonymous internet users cannot access records that are sealed, expunged, automatically confidential, or made confidential by court order.
| Record | What it can show | What it does not prove by itself |
|---|---|---|
| Arrest/booking | Arrest event, booking, incoming charges, custody or bond information when published. | Conviction or final filed charge. |
| Police or sheriff report | Officer narrative, allegations, incident details, and agency documentation. | That every allegation was proven. |
| Court docket | Filed case, hearings, motions, accessible documents, and disposition. | A complete statewide criminal history. |
| FDLE history | Florida statewide criminal-history information available through FDLE. | Out-of-state or every federal record. |
For a staff-assisted Monroe County criminal-record search letter, the Clerk’s criminal FAQ currently lists $2 per year per person searched, $1 per page for copies, and $2 per document for certification. The Clerk says this search covers Monroe County information only and payment must be received before the search is conducted.
How to request a Key West police or sheriff arrest report
Key West Police report
Use the City of Key West Records Management page or the public-record request link on the Key West Police Department page.
Police Department:
1604 North Roosevelt Boulevard
Key West, FL 33040
305-809-1111
Monroe County Sheriff report
Use the official MCSO Public Records portal when the Sheriff’s Office created the report.
MCSO Headquarters:
5525 College Road
Key West, FL 33040
305-292-7000
The City’s public-record guidance says requests can be made without explaining why you want the record. Its FAQ also says arrest reports prepared after an arrest are generally open for inspection, while protected information—such as certain victim information—can be exempt. Florida law allows an agency to redact exempt material and provide the nonexempt remainder.
A short request that is easier for staff to process
Please provide the arrest/incident report for: Name: [full legal name] Arrest or incident date: [date or date range] Agency/report/booking number: [if known] Location: [if known] Electronic copy preferred. If fees or extensive staff time will be required, please provide a cost estimate before processing.
Be specific. “All records about John Smith” can require much more searching than a request with an arrest date and report number.
Need more than Monroe County? Use FDLE for Florida criminal history
A Key West or Monroe County search is local. If the question is whether a person has a public criminal history elsewhere in Florida, use the Florida Department of Law Enforcement criminal-history service.
| FDLE option | Current published cost | Useful when |
|---|---|---|
| Instant Search | $24 search + $1 credit-card processing fee | You want immediate, non-certified Florida results that can be printed or emailed. |
| Certified / Non-Certified Search | $24 | You need FDLE staff to process the request. FDLE currently lists about 5 business days for non-certified and 6–7 business days for certified processing, not including mail delivery. |
FDLE is Florida’s central repository for criminal-history information. This is different from a Sheriff booking search and different from the Monroe County court index.
Active warrants are a separate search
If your real question is whether there is an active Monroe County warrant, use the official MCSO Active Warrants page. A warrant is not the same thing as a past arrest, a current inmate record, or a conviction.
Public access, copy fees, and records that may be restricted
Florida Statutes section 119.07 generally requires public-record custodians to permit inspection and copying, respond promptly and in good faith, and identify the legal basis when an exemption is asserted. You can read the official statute on the Florida Senate website.
The City of Key West currently states that standard one-sided copies may be charged up to 15 cents per page where no other fee is prescribed, and certified copies may be charged up to $1 per copy. Extensive use of staff or information-technology resources can create an additional reasonable service charge. Ask for an estimate before requesting a large date range.
Some information will not be public. Common examples include sealed or expunged records, confidential court matters, certain juvenile information, and protected victim or personal information. A blank online search result therefore does not prove that an arrest or case never existed.
If the record is yours: correction, sealing, and expungement are different
If information is wrong, the first issue is correction: identify which agency or court has the inaccurate entry and provide the controlling documentation. If the information is accurate but you want to know whether Florida law allows it to be sealed or expunged, use FDLE’s official process rather than assuming a dismissed case automatically disappears.
FDLE says the first step for court-ordered sealing or expungement is applying for a Certificate of Eligibility. The current instructions call for a completed application, certified disposition for the listed case or charges, fingerprints from an authorized criminal-justice agency, and a $75 nonrefundable FDLE processing fee. FDLE currently says eligibility processing typically takes about 12 weeks after a complete packet is received.
The certificate is not the final order. If FDLE issues it, the applicant still files the required petition, certificate, and affidavit in the court with jurisdiction. FDLE recommends keeping copies of the arrest report, certified disposition, and court orders before a record is sealed or expunged.
How to avoid the most common search mistakes
- Do not match on name alone. Compare date of birth or age, arrest date, agency, location, case number, or other official identifiers when available.
- Do not confuse Key West with all of Monroe County. The Sheriff’s system is countywide.
- Do not call a booking charge a conviction. Verify the final case through the Clerk.
- Do not assume “no result” means “no record.” Search scope, confidentiality, sealing, spelling, and indexing can affect results.
- Use certified records when the task requires certification. A screenshot from a booking page is not a certified criminal-record document.
Recent-Arrests.org is an independent informational publication, not a government agency. See our editorial policy. If you find an incorrect link, jurisdiction, or factual statement on this page, use our corrections and privacy request process.
Key West arrest records: 10 frequently asked questions
1. How do I check recent Key West arrests?
Start with the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office Current Arrests page. Because the Sheriff’s system is countywide, confirm that the arrest location or agency actually relates to Key West. Then check Current Inmates for custody status and the Monroe County Clerk court search for the filed case and later outcome.
2. Are Key West arrest records the same as Monroe County arrest records?
No. Key West is in Monroe County, and county systems can contain arrests from across the Florida Keys. A Monroe County booking is not automatically a Key West arrest. Check the arrest location and arresting agency before describing the event as a Key West arrest.
3. Can I search Key West arrest records for free?
The Monroe County Sheriff’s online Current Arrests, Arrest Search, Current Inmates, and Active Warrants pages are public access tools, and the Clerk provides online court-record searching. Fees can apply when you order copies, certifications, staff-assisted searches, or a statewide FDLE criminal-history check.
4. How do I find an older Key West arrest?
Use the Monroe County Sheriff’s Arrest Search rather than relying only on the Current Arrests page. Then search the Monroe County Clerk’s criminal case records by name or case number. If the report itself is needed, request it from the law-enforcement agency that created it.
5. How do I know if someone is still in jail?
Use the Monroe County Sheriff’s Current Inmates page. A recent arrest entry does not prove that a person is still in custody, because release, bond, transfer, or other status changes can occur after booking.
6. How do I get a Key West police arrest report?
If Key West Police created the report, use the City of Key West public-records request process or contact the Police Department at 1604 North Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040, phone 305-809-1111. If the Monroe County Sheriff created the report, use the Sheriff’s public-record request portal instead.
7. How do I verify what happened after the arrest?
Search the Monroe County Clerk’s criminal court records. The court docket is the better source for filed charges, hearings, documents that are remotely available, and the disposition. Do not treat the original booking charge as the final court result.
8. How do I run a statewide Florida criminal-history search?
Use the Florida Department of Law Enforcement criminal-history service. FDLE currently lists a $24 fee for a public Florida criminal-history search; its Instant Search also lists a $1 credit-card processing fee. A county arrest search is not a statewide background check.
9. Why might an arrest or court record not appear online?
Possible reasons include a name mismatch, search limitations, a record that is not yet indexed, a record that is sealed or expunged, a confidential case type, or a case that never produced the court filing you expected. A missing online result does not prove that no arrest or case exists.
10. Can a Key West arrest record be sealed or expunged?
Some Florida records may qualify, but eligibility depends on the specific history and case outcome. FDLE says the first step for court-ordered sealing or expungement is applying for a Certificate of Eligibility. The certificate itself does not seal the record; a petition must still be filed in the court with jurisdiction.
Use the shortest official path for the answer you need
For most searches, the practical order is simple: check MCSO Current Arrests, verify Current Inmates if custody matters, use the Arrest Search for older events, and finish with the Monroe County Clerk to confirm the court case. Request the police or sheriff report only when you need the underlying narrative, and use FDLE when the question extends beyond Monroe County.